Best Password Manager (Tested): 1Password vs NordPass vs Bitwarden vs Proton Pass

Scope: This guide focuses on password managers for individuals and families. If you're evaluating options for a business or team—where SSO integration, admin controls, and compliance matter—see our dedicated Best Business Password Managers guide.

The difference between a frustrating password manager and a great one usually comes down to two things: how it handles two-factor authentication and what happens when you switch devices. This guide breaks down the leading options to help you choose the right one.

Comparison Overview

All prices shown are annual billing equivalents. Promotional rates (especially NordPass 2-year plans) may be lower.

---

Choosing Based on Your Situation

Before diving into details, here's guidance for common scenarios:

If you refuse to pay a subscription

Bitwarden is the only option that doesn't gate essential security features behind a paywall. Unlimited passwords, unlimited devices, and zero-knowledge encryption—all free. Proton Pass is a close second with a generous free tier that includes 10 email aliases.

If you're setting up a family

1Password Families has the most mature family management features, including account recovery if someone forgets their password. NordPass Family covers 6 users instead of 5, though the interface is less refined for family coordination.

If privacy is your priority

Proton Pass fits naturally if you're already using Proton Mail or VPN, or if you're actively reducing reliance on Google services. The Swiss jurisdiction, open-source code, and integrated email aliases align with a privacy-focused approach. If you're still using Gmail and Chrome daily, the email aliases will feel less integrated.

If you want the most polished experience

1Password has been refined over nearly 20 years and consistently leads in user experience design, particularly on iOS and macOS.

If you're technical and want control

Bitwarden with self-hosting. You can run your own Bitwarden server, ensuring your vault never touches third-party infrastructure.

If you're a small business

1Password Business or Bitwarden Enterprise have the most mature admin features, SSO integration, and compliance certifications. NordPass Teams is a more affordable option for smaller teams with simpler needs.

---

Passkeys: A Key Differentiator

Passkeys are passwordless credentials that can't be phished or reused. As more websites adopt them, how well your password manager handles passkeys across devices matters.

If you frequently switch between iPhone and Windows, or Android and Mac, pay attention to how seamlessly each manager syncs passkeys. 1Password and NordPass currently offer the smoothest experience in mixed-ecosystem setups.

---

Understanding Pricing

Password manager pricing varies significantly based on subscription length and promotions. Here's what to expect with annual billing (the most common option):

---

Understanding Password Manager Security

All four managers use zero-knowledge architecture—the company cannot access your unencrypted data. However, there are meaningful differences in implementation.

Encryption Methods

AES-256 (1Password, Proton Pass, Bitwarden) is the established standard, approved for U.S. government classified information. Decades of analysis have found no practical vulnerabilities.

XChaCha20 (NordPass) is a newer standard designed by cryptographer Daniel J. Bernstein. It's considered equally secure and may perform better on devices without hardware AES acceleration. Both are excellent choices.

1Password's Secret Key

1Password uses a unique approach: in addition to your master password, you receive a 34-character Secret Key when creating your account. Both are required to decrypt your vault on a new device.

This means an attacker who learns your master password still cannot access your vault without the Secret Key. The tradeoff: you must store the Secret Key safely. When you create your account, 1Password generates an "Emergency Kit" PDF containing this key—this PDF is the most important document in your digital life. Print it and store it somewhere secure. If you lose both your master password and Secret Key, your vault is unrecoverable.

Open Source vs. Proprietary

Bitwarden and Proton Pass publish their source code publicly, allowing security researchers to audit and verify claims. Both have undergone independent security audits.

1Password and NordPass are proprietary but have also completed third-party security audits. NordPass publishes audit results, and 1Password maintains a bug bounty program.

---

Detailed Reviews

1Password

1Password has been a leading password manager since 2006. It's known for a polished user experience and comprehensive feature set.

Key Strengths:

• User Interface: 1Password invests heavily in design. The apps feel consistent across platforms, with logical organization and smooth workflows—particularly on iOS and macOS where the experience feels native.

• Watchtower: Monitors your vault for weak passwords, reused credentials, compromised accounts, and sites where you haven't enabled two-factor authentication. Provides actionable recommendations.

• Family Features: The Families plan includes a family organizer who can help recover accounts if a family member forgets their master password. Shared vaults simplify managing household credentials.

• Travel Mode: Temporarily removes designated vaults from your devices. Useful for international travel.

Considerations:

• No Free Tier: 1Password offers only a 14-day trial. If you need a long-term free solution, consider Bitwarden or Proton Pass.

• Secret Key Management: The Secret Key adds security but requires careful storage. If you lose both your master password and Secret Key, your vault is unrecoverable.

• Desktop Apps: Built with Electron. Some users find these less responsive than the previous native versions, though performance is generally acceptable on modern hardware.

Pricing (Annual Billing):

---

NordPass

NordPass is developed by Nord Security (NordVPN). It entered the market in 2019 and has developed into a competitive option with aggressive pricing.

Key Strengths:

• Pricing: NordPass frequently offers promotions that make it one of the most affordable premium options, particularly on 2-year plans.

• XChaCha20 Encryption: A modern encryption choice that performs well across devices.

• Email Masking: Premium plans include unique email address generation for signups, protecting your primary email from spam.

• Mobile Experience: The iOS and Android apps are well-designed with reliable autofill.

Considerations:

• Free Tier Limitations: The free plan allows only one device at a time, which limits practical usefulness.

• Renewal Pricing: Promotional rates (especially 2-year plans) are significantly lower than renewal rates. Check the full subscription cost.

• No Self-Hosting: Not an option if you need to run your own infrastructure.

Pricing (Annual Billing):

NordPass pricing varies by subscription length and current promotions.

---

Proton Pass

Proton Pass launched in 2023 from Proton AG, the Swiss company behind Proton Mail and Proton VPN. It benefits from Proton's established reputation in privacy-focused services.

Key Strengths:

• Generous Free Tier: Unlimited passwords on unlimited devices, plus 10 email aliases—rare for a free plan.

• Email Aliases (Hide-my-email): Proton acquired SimpleLogin in 2022 and integrated its technology. Generate unique email addresses for each service to protect your primary address and identify data sellers.

• Ecosystem Integration: If you already use Proton Mail or VPN, Proton Pass integrates naturally. The Proton Unlimited plan ($9.99/mo) includes all Proton services.

• Open Source: Publicly auditable code with completed third-party security audits.

Considerations:

• Ecosystem Dependency: Proton Pass works best within the Proton ecosystem. If you're using Gmail and Chrome daily, the email aliases won't integrate as seamlessly—forwarding to Gmail works, but the experience is smoother with Proton Mail.

• Newer Product: Some organizational features (nested folders, tagging) are less mature than competitors who've had more time to refine them.

• Business Features: Enterprise features are less developed compared to 1Password or Bitwarden.

Pricing (Annual Billing):

Monthly billing rates are higher (e.g., Pass Plus is $2.99/mo if billed monthly).

---

Bitwarden

Bitwarden launched in 2016 and has become the go-to recommendation for users seeking a free, open-source password manager. It's transparent about its security practices and offers features that competitors charge for.

Key Strengths:

• Free Tier: Unlimited passwords, unlimited devices, password generator, and basic two-step login—all at no cost. For many users, the free tier is sufficient.

• Open Source and Audited: All code is public with multiple completed third-party security audits.

• Self-Hosting: Deploy on your own server for complete control over your data.

• Bitwarden Send: Securely share encrypted text or files with anyone, including non-Bitwarden users.

• Affordability: The $10/year premium plan is significantly cheaper than any competitor.

Considerations:

• Interface: The interface is dense and utilitarian, favoring text lists over visual icons. For users comfortable with software, this is fine. For less technical users (parents, older relatives), the mobile autofill experience can occasionally require extra taps compared to 1Password's smoother iOS integration.

• Premium for Advanced Features: TOTP (2FA codes), emergency access, and vault health reports require the $10/year premium plan.

Pricing (Annual Billing):

---

Setting Up for Success

Regardless of which password manager you choose, follow these practices:

Create a Strong Master Password

Your master password is the one password you need to remember. Make it:

• Long: At least 16 characters, ideally longer
• Unique: Never used for any other account
• Memorable: A passphrase (multiple words) is often easier to remember than random characters

Example approaches:

• A sentence with substitutions: My-dog-ate-17-tacos-on-Tuesday!
• Random words: correct-horse-battery-staple (but use more words)

Enable Two-Factor Authentication

Protect your vault with an additional factor:

• TOTP apps (Google Authenticator, Authy)
• Hardware keys (YubiKey, FIDO2)
• Biometric unlock (after initial authentication)

Set Up Emergency Access

All four password managers offer some form of emergency access:

• 1Password: Family organizers can help recover accounts
• NordPass: Emergency access for trusted contacts
• Proton Pass: Account recovery through Proton account
• Bitwarden: Emergency access with configurable waiting period

Configure this before you need it.

---

Migrating from Your Current Password Manager

Switching is straightforward. Here's the general process:

Step 1: Export from Your Current Manager

Most export to CSV format:

• Chrome: Settings → Passwords → Download file
• Safari: System Settings → Passwords → Export
• LastPass: Account Options → Advanced → Export
• Dashlane: My Account → Export Data

Step 2: Import to Your New Manager

All four managers support CSV imports:

• 1Password: File → Import → Select source
• NordPass: Settings → Import Items
• Proton Pass: Settings → Import
• Bitwarden: Tools → Import Data

Step 3: Verify and Clean Up

After importing:

1. Verify a few important logins work correctly
2. Delete the exported CSV file (it contains unencrypted passwords)
3. Disable your browser's built-in password saving
4. Remove passwords from your old manager

---

Summary

Any of these four options will meaningfully improve your password security. The most important step is choosing one and using it consistently.

---

Each password manager in this guide uses zero-knowledge encryption and has been audited by third parties. Your choice should be based on your specific needs—whether that's price, privacy, family features, or enterprise capabilities.

---

Related Resources

• Best Business Password Managers — SSO, admin controls, and team deployment guide
• 1Password vs Built-in Password Managers — When browser managers aren't enough
• Password Managers for AI Threat Protection — Security comparison for emerging threats
• Best VPN for Remote Work — Secure your connection alongside your passwords
• Passkeys for Small Business — Implementation guide for passwordless authentication